February 20, 2012

Blogs vs. Forums

I've been mulling this over since I started my blog last month: what is it about blogging (and reading blogs) that provides a more fulfilling outlet and comforts me more than being a member of an infertility forum?

Last year, when I chucked out the last of my BCPs and declared we were officially "trying" (haha, how young and naive..), I started google searching infertility and PCOS. I knew I was going to need support for this journey and I really didn't know what was out there. I happened upon a PCOS group and lurked for about a week before joining. It was a pretty eye opening experience. Kind of like immersing yourself in a foreign country to learn a new language, joining a forum tossed me into the deep end where I had to quickly figure out the lingo or be out of the loop forever (that was way too many metaphors for one sentence).

I was active in that forum for almost a year. I was supportive over countless BFNs, BFPs, and so many heart-breaking miscarriages. I watched women come and go. I talked newbies through all the obsessing of the first few TTC cycles. I was a cheerleader for the women who had been there for nearly a decade without getting a take-home baby. But after many months and only 2 ovulatory cycles for myself, I started to feel...left behind, I guess. Sometimes a girl would join and be pregnant the very next month. Other girls only took a few more medicated cycles and they too were off to the pregnancy threads. Some girls took longer to phase out of newbie status and reading the onslaught of Panic! posts got kind of old. For the hundredth time sweetie, when you're taking progesterone supplements during your 2ww, you really can't symptom spot - the supplements can cause every symptom under the sun... I don't know how the veteran members kept it up, month after month. There was a core of women that stayed fairly constant, but the rest was a revolving door of ladies fortunate enough to not need much, if any, medical intervention. And while I didn't mind playing the positive thinker for others, I was feeling very negative about my own state of affairs. The helpful, supportive comments from others started to grate on my nerves.

Finally, after the massive failure that was clomid round 4 (150mg), I threw up my hands. I knew it was time to find an RE and that my TTC journey was not going to be as simple as I'd hoped. And if it was going to take so much more time and effort, I couldn't handle watching half a dozen women get their BFP every other month while I sat on the sidelines just waiting. So I said goodbye to the forum for now. Maybe I'll go back someday if Dr. B finds a drug protocol that gets me ovulating regularly, but I don't know.

Blogging is somehow so different from being part of a forum. I enjoy the slower pace of things; life is taken day by day instead of by cycle milestones. I get to know the individual bloggers on a more personal and detailed level - not just by the TTC history in their signature. And its easier to find other women who are "in it for the long haul", so to speak. Am I terrible for saying that? I hope you understand what I mean. I'm grateful that, for the first time in a long time, I'm not just talking to a wall when I blog. I kept my old online journal private when we started TTC because I figured none of my followers were interested. Its comforting to send my thoughts out into the void where they might be useful to another person, if only to validate their feelings or help them not feel so alone. Even though a forum is essentially, an unending conversation, I think blogging is a *better* medium for communication. I am able to more actively participate in the ALI community now that I have this blog. And I don't feel like I'm just sitting on the sidelines while everyone else moves forward - because even though I'm not actively TTC right now, I still have a story and that story still matters. That's something I didn't think I could have in a forum.

So thank you to everyone who makes this community exist! Without it, I'd be lost. Do you have an opinion on the uses of forums and blogs? Do you prefer one or the other? Use both?

12 comments:

  1. I too started off in a forum. I quickly realized that I needed to move from the general TTC forum (those TTC newbies just had no idea that not everyone gets preggo within the first few tries) to the 'This isn't working like it's supposed to' forum. Unfortunately even there the BFPs were hard to take. I'm one of the few left, though I've found myself slowly moving away from it. I had the exact same feelings of being left behind. I feel the same way about this community of blogs. It's comforting and I like that. More than that, I need it.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I use both, but I have the same problem with some of the forums as you. Especially after my diagnosis, and as I hit all the milestones (my due date, a year trying, a year from the miscarriage) I started to separate from the larger online communities. I have found a lot of support in private forums with fewer people. Still, no one has the problems I have, but they're more supportive on a personal level.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I agree with you very much. I do still check forums on occasion and always regret when I do. It's usually depressing or gives me false hope, one or the other. Blogs are way better, as you can really get to know people, like you said.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I agree... I was never active on the forums because when I looked at them I was completely overwhelmed. Just a constant stream of information and questions, not people interacting on a personal basis at all. I like blogs because you don't have to explain yourself and your whole back story every single time, you can just move forward and write what you want.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I joined a couple of forums and never really got involved in it. It did seem kind of impersonal while blogging seems to really connect you to people. There are girls I've "met" through blogging that I feel like I really know and that we would be friends IRL if we lived close. It has been an incredible experience for me, I'm thankful to have found this community.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I agree with everything. I was a member of a forum for awhile, but like you I soon felt out of place. I found myself getting more anxious during the TWW or analyzing other peoples symptoms in regards to my own. I became a crazy person. So I quit. There was one thread that I got to know the woman very well and I still check in with them, but I don't venture into any other part of the board because I know it was bad for me.

    Blogging is so different. I feel like I belong in this community and the level of support feels so much higher to me. I am so grateful to this little family on the internet.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Oh, so true - the women in forums feed off each others' neuroses and get whipped up into a frenzy over every imagined symptom. Waaaay too stressful for me after so many cycles where I *thought* I Oed and actually did not :-P

      Delete
  7. I know forums can be helpful for some, but to be honest, I kind of loathe them. Mainly because people don't feel as obligated to correctly spell and punctuate and it drives me insane. Also because of everything you just said. And I feel like, as a blogger, I have my own little space and you have your own little space, and we visit each other occasionally and it's much more like being virtual neighbors.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Virtual neighbors - I like that! And it does make me more comfortable to have my fenced space and you have your fenced space and we can comment about each others' landscaping now and then... LOL. And I didn't mention it, but yeah, the terrible spelling and grammar in forums drives me up a wall!!

      Delete
  8. Part of the reason I started writing a blog is because I couldn't make sense of the forums. I was terrible at distinguishing between valid, medically based advice and people’s general thoughts on how things should work, which was very frustrating for me. Once I found the community of IF blogs, I loved learning from everyone and became invested in their experiences. So far, I’ve found everyone to be wonderfully supportive.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Most time it`s good to share problem. WHO KNOWS??
    I suffered Adhesions that damaged my uterus and this is really what i think you should understand.
    I finally was able to conceive a child to my own the year 2016 after 21 years without any issue. this really was the worst thing ever. It was a miracle that indeed shocked me. because i was left with no option but to use a Herbal Health Concoction that was prepared from Herbs to help the Immune. I got to find out about this from someone and i talked to the direct source about my problem. He`s name is Dwr Dexter and HE told me how some necessary few herbs will be useful as to women`s health and recovery and he had to do what knows best. He sent the Herbs to me and gave instruction on method of use. this all happened and i really have been able to say i`m glad God did this.
    You can congratulate me (201) 426-7860 but dont call at bed time..
    You can get in-touch with Dexter via Email (Dexterherbs@dr.com)
    Really just felt like dropping this, not for all THO!!!.,

    ReplyDelete